Home » Blog » Reindeer Sandwiches

Reindeer Sandwiches

This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.

Sharing is caring!

Reindeer Sandwiches

Add some holiday cheer to your kids lunch box this season with the adorable Reindeer Sandwiches.  Peanut Butter and Jelly gets taken to the next level in just a few minutes and only requires a simple Heart Shaped Cookie Cutter.

Truthfully you can make these with any filling, but I’m sticking to simple and adorable during the hectic holiday season.  Gather together your supplies:

  1. Peanut Butter & Jam
  2. Sandwich Bread
  3. M&M’s and mini chocolate chips
  4. Heart Shaped cookie cutter
Heart shaped cookie cutter on a piece of white bread.
Cut out heart shapes from the sandwich bread for the Reindeer head.
White bread slices cut into heart shapes with peanut butter and jelly on them.
Spread peanut butter on three hearts and jam on 3 hears.
Tuck pretzels into the top of the sandwich to form the antlers
Add mini chocolate chips to form eyes and an m&m for the nose.
Yield: 3

Reindeer Sandwiches

Reindeer Sandwiches
Prep Time 10 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes


  • 6 slices thin sandwich bread, white or brown
  • heart shaped cookie cutter
  • Peanut butter
  • Jelly, any flavor
  • 6 pretzels
  • 6 mini chocolate chips
  • 3 red M&M's candies


  1. Place bread on a cutting board and cut out six heart shapes. Set aside.
  2. Put peanut butter on three of the hearts and jelly on three of the hearts.
  3. Place pieces together. Stick two pretzels at the top of each side of the heart for antlers.
  4. Add two chocolate chips for eyes and a M&M for the nose. Use a little peanut butter to make them stay in place.


M&M's can be red for rudolph or brown.

By on December 5th, 2019
Click on this image to get a free 30 day meal planning printable.
Download the free Meal Planning Prompts now

Want more great recipes?

For more great family friendly recipes, Meal plans, LIVE stream Quick Cook and Meal Prep Video’s plus so much more, join the Love on a Plate Facebook community now.   

Do you find yourself asking What’s for Dinner?

We also have a YouTube channel  Be sure to subscribe to get access to some amazing exclusive content. 

And of course we have a Pinterest Board for lots of great Instant Pot, Meal Planning, Family Friendly, amazing recipes to keep you inspired! Follow me here: https://www.pinterest.ca/larabrooks/

Did you make this recipe?

We’d love to know what you think of these recipes if you try them!  Share a picture on IG using #loveonaplate,  Post your picture on the Love on A Plate group, leave a Comment and Rating below.  I think you get the picture!  We want to hear from you.  @loveonaplate.ca

Lara Brooks

About loveonaplate

Foodie, Chef, Mother,

More posts by this author.

1 thought on “Reindeer Sandwiches”

Leave a comment

Skip to Recipe